2015
- Midfielder - Michael Bruley - Southern Methodist University
2017
- Defenseman - Alex Eubank - Lindenwood University
- FOGO - Hudson Bearden - Jacksonville University (transferred to Southwestern University)
- Midfielder - JP Morris - Mount St. Mary's University
2018
- Attackman - Alex Weis - Lindenwood University
- Attackman - Mike Bannon - Western New England University
- Defenseman - Aidan Gildea - Southwestern University
- Defenseman - Jordan Sullivan - Lincoln Memorial University
- Defenseman - Ryan Thompson - University of Texas
- LSM - Kyle Kooda - University of Utah (transferred to SMU)
- FOGO - Michael Miocic - Lindenwood University
- Midfielder - Phillip Watters - Lindenwood University (transferred to Piedmont)
2019
- Attackman - Caleb Holdridge - Coast Guard Academy
- Defenseman - Aidan Kennedy - Baldwin Wallace University
- Defenseman - Bauer Aucoin - Quincy University
- Defenseman - Corey Healy - Colorado State University - Pueblo
- Defenseman - Jack Barrett - Southwestern University
- Goalie - Hunter Morgan - University of Tampa
- Goalie - JC Higginbotham - Bellarmine University
- Midfielder - Cameron Hamway - UMBC
- Midfielder - Conor Beckett - Southwestern University
- Midfielder - Kyle Srichantra - Quincy University
- Midfielder - Mason Gayle - Southwestern University
- Midfielder - Matthew Caldwell - Southwestern University
- Midfielder - Zach Loftis - Belmont Abbey College
2020
- Attackman - Blaine Lowrance - Quincy University
- Attackman - Brian Allmer - New York Institute of Technology
- Attackman - Bryce Washington - University of Michigan-Dearborn
- Attackman - Chase Bonds - Southwestern University
- Defenseman - Demariah Wesley - Hampton University
- Defenseman - Jacob McCoy - Lindenwood University
- LSM - Joey Rosen - St. John's University
- Midfielder - Cameron Johnson - University of Massachusetts - U17 US National Team Captain
- Midfielder - Josh Healy - Bellarmine University
- Midfielder - Kimoni Greene - Hampton University
- Midfielder - Sam Dulle - Elmhurst College
- Midfielder - Titus McGowan - Southern Methodist University
- Midfielder - Trevor Lagaard - University of Indianapolis
- Midfielder - Will Michael - Elmhurst College
2021
- Midfielder - Jake Griffin - Holy Cross University